
NHS doctors who inflict intimate and agonising surgery on women with NO anaesthetic. Hetty Baynes was subjected to a uterine biopsy and was left screaming in pain after the procedure
- Hetty Baynes was due to have a routine examination for uterine fibroids
- What actually happened left her bedridden for five days
- Hetty’s GP was shocked when she relayed the story afterwards
- She says she will now be looking to get private health insurance to stop anything like this happening again
“Arriving at the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital two weeks ago for my long-awaited appointment, my mind was already on the pleasures I had planned for the next day.
“This meeting with a gynaecologist had been in the diary for three months, so it was hardly urgent, and I had no reason to doubt I would be in good spirits for my son’s 22nd birthday celebrations 24 hours later.
“Little did I know that within half an hour I would be emerging from the consultant’s office in a state of shock, having been through one of the most physically traumatic experiences of my life.”
2. Kelly, USA – Mine was quick however it was the only time I’ve screamed the f word in the doctors office. I’m American with private healthcare.
3. Bernie, Longford, Ireland – You don’t get an anaesthetic for a biopsy of cervix either and it can be very painful.
4. Sarah, Portsmouth, United Kingdom – I am shocked at the negative comments, perhaps those women were lucky to have a higher pain threshold or a gentler doctor. I had treatment for pre cancerous cells of the cervix and it was like torture, It hurt so much I screamed and as the appointment was at 8pm when I got home and found I was bleeding profusely I had nobody to contact as the clinic and my GP surgery were closed, I was traumatised. To be fair, the doctor DID offer a general, but only because I was sobbing, his words were “if I don’t do this you will get cancer”, hardly going to comfort me. We are treated like an inconvenience, they have to treat us because we are lucky to have smear tests to test for these cells, but it’s like it’s our fault we ended up in the clinic..
5. paulinelowe, Lampeter, United Kingdom – I had the same procedure about 16 years ago. I went in for a routine check after previously having laser treatment for pre cancerous cells. when the doctor thought she saw something and wanted to take a biopsy. I agreed that she could do it there and then as I had one before under local anaesthetic. I expected to fell the pin prick of the needle but instead to my horror I felt the searing pain of my flesh being cut. My body went into shock, My stomach seemed to grow twice in size (or at least feel that way) and my mind could not comprehend what had just happened. Confused I left and was driven home. A few days later I went to my GP to complain. The outcome was she changed the hospital that I was sent to for any other follow ups. I still feel some sort of action should have been taken against the doctor.
6. lovestosew, Denver, United States – The patients also need to ask questions about anesthesia for procedures like this. No one is truly responsible for your health but yourself, ask questions. I can tell you this is not something I would have without a general anesthetic.
7. Adopt-A-Rescue-Dog, Sydney, Australia – You DO need to take action! The Doctor breached medical ethics by not explaining the REAL pain u may experience. This should have been made known PRE-PROCEDURE. Otherwise, any consent you give is deemed invalid. Your GP was right as to the Malpractice side of things. Once you started showing signs of distress, the procedure must be halted and your concerns discussed. This procedure is in violation to every person’s right to pain free treatment should they feel they require it. You were not offered the choice hence the doctor and NHS have legally failed. I urge you to not let this drop. You can sue without seeking compensation. Push that the UK Medical Regulations are changed so that every patient receives detailed information about any procedure they are booked in for and that they receive this at the time of making the appointment to have the procedure carried out. This then gives patients time to make the decisions you were not able to make.
8. shelle1975, yorkshire, United Kingdom – To all of you so brave women telling other women to “grow up” Shame on you … Everyone is different … Doing these procedures in GP clinic saves money pure and simple … Plus the cost of monitoring after.
9. Ecclescake, North – Why do people that had an OK experience tell those that didn’t they’re being pathetic? We are all different and Dr’s perform their task in different ways, so each woman’s experience is their own. I’ve had an ectopic bleed (with subsequent emergency surgery) referred to me having a bad period pain and the triage nurse actually tell the consultant (a man) to treat an ectopic pregnancy and stop being an idiot. The triage nurse clearly anticipating why I was rolling about in agony. I’ve also had a colposcopy, with biopsy, where I was told to cough and I wouldn’t feel a thing, again by a male consultant. It hurt, I had tears streaming down my cheeks, but had the most tender nurse who brushed them away. I appreciate my experiences are my own, but NO-ONE brave or not deserves to have a procedure with no explanation about expected pain, or when in pain be treated like it’s not happening.
10. superduper1, Cirencester – I had exactly the same procedure done about 5 years ago and it can only be described as medieval torture. No woman should be expected to endure this sort of pain in this day and age. I am sure a man would not stand for it. My best friend also had the same thing done. It is traumatic and any woman who disagrees must be some kind of android
11. null – After having a colonoscopy and an endoscopy and IUD insertions and removals without anaesthetic, I did have to laugh at my consultants notes, which said, “Patient tolerated procedures without anaesthesia.” Patient was not offered any!
12. Grumpy Lady, The Shore of Helm – I’ve had a cervical biopsy with no anaesthetic; agony
13. Diana, Newcastle under Lyme, United Kingdom – I know anaesthetics carry a risk, but surely women should be given the choice of having pain relief or not.
14. lyndylou, Sheffield – Absolutely. Women usually have an idea how much pain they can take. Surely also if a woman is in obvious agony, the procedure should be stopped and an anaesthetic offered.
15. Mrs D, Donegal – It is not simple for some women, and the clue comes from the nurse telling her she was brave. I would have run then!
16. pussinflipflops, Doncaster – 7 weeks ago I went through the same thing.. yes, it was very, very painful to take a sample of the fibroids I have. I wasn’t given any choice of anaesthetic. Sadly there are cancerous cells and I’m dreading the hysterectomy I am scheduled to have in 2weeks time.
17. Brookles, Birmingham, United Kingdom – I had a uterine biopsy then a hysteroscopy in December 2014. Exactly the same thing happened to me at the Women’s Hospital in Birmingham. I asked for anaesthetic as I’d had a Colposcopy a few years ago and still remember the pain I was told it wouldn’t hurt – it b….y well did hurt I screamed and cried with the shock of the pain. I’m usually quite hardy but this was horrendous. I did get a cup of tea though. But no cake. I ended up in bed for the afternoon as I was in such pain. Not even a paracetamol was offered. This cannot be right surely?
18. Highlandlassie, Argyll – I had an HSG performed recently and the letter advised that this may be uncomfortable. I took Voltarol and paracetamol and was so glad I did. There were 2 nurses there holding me, with one stroking my hair, which was extremely unnerving. I’d say the pain was on a par with my C section recovery but intense and searing, I never let on I was in that much pain due to the fact they kept saying “there it’s not as bad as you thought eh?’And I thought they would laugh at me. The woman before me took nothing and screamed blue murder. I think they are trying to avoid giving out pain relief.
19. Trumpydalston, Chester – I had this procedure also without anaesthetic. The male consultant who arranged it said it would be ‘a bit uncomfortable’. It was agonising pain!
20. Jenny from Maidstone, West Malling – I was offered this test and told by the doctor “most women who have had a baby can tolerate this”. I asked her to explain the procedure in detail saying afterwards,“I don’t like the sound of that so no thanks – can I have a scan first?”The scan showed no invasive was needed.
21. danny7morgan, London – Sounds like government backed misrepresentation and assault to me.
22. DonutUniverse, London – Grounds for legal action surely, but as stated she’s not looking for money from the NHS. Medical practices will try it on and save money by holding back meds. You have to be aware of it and raise hell if it any of them try it on with you. I suspect they target women more because they are often less aggressive and less likely to react. Always ask clearly at the outset what kind of sedation to expect.
23. loula71, – I had to have a biopsy of my cervix due to abnormal cells. The male doctor said it will only hurt a little . I had two nurses either side while the butcher of a doctor chopped a small amount of my cervix away without anaesthetic. I screamed in agony and was crumpled up in pain for days. It was the worst procedure but would have been a walk in the park with a general anaesthetic.
24. Rebecca, Swansea – Clearly it should be done under anaesthetic or it wouldn’t be offered to people in other hospitals. The hospital’s response is totally unrepentant and shows a real lack of compassion. Doctors should have to answer for what can surely be classed as misconduct.
25. Mrs Very Grumpy, Belfast, United Kingdom – As a young student nurse back in the 70s I worked for a short while in the gastoenterology procedure unit as part of my training. I can only describe it as the chamber of horrors and at 19 years old felt almost as traumatised as the patients. People who had difficulties swallowing the gastroscope for a gastroscopy were irritants and time wasters – I won’t even get into the sigmoidoscopy and colonoscopy patients who requested “something for the pain please”. The patient/doctor relationship was very different at that time and patients were less inclined to ask for sedation and placed complete trust in their doctor with no questions asked. Nowadays, we are armed with all the information we need to decide for ourselves whether we want sedation at the outset or to start without it and see how it goes first. It should be a decision you take with your doctor and not one they make on your behalf – no one knows you better than yourself.
26. Adie the ranter, Prestayn, United Kingdom – My Mrs had this and she’s no wuss but she passed out with the pain in the car on the way home.
27. DawnTX, Tomball, United States – The same type of painful experience happened to me, once during egg harvesting for IVF in the UK (the doctor said “Oh that shouldn’t be hurting you” as I was screaming with tears gushing out of my eyes) and the second time a year ago in the US during a routine biopsy for the same reason as Ms Baynes and, of course, healthcare here is all “private” in a sense. I don’t understand how those female doctors can say “there, there dear” in the way they do. I agree it’s brutality for no good reason.
28. Kitty, UK – My 98 year old grandmother had this done when attending hospital for investigations into a prolapsed uterus. We weren’t expecting it and it was clearly painful. She gritted her teeth and didn’t make a sound but the sight of her flinching made me cry and she was gripping my hand so tight. I was angry that they just invaded her body with no explanation. She passed away a few months later at 99 years old and the problem never left her. At that age women just put up with things but I would not have agreed to have it done without anaesthetic of some kind.
29. hellsbells, London – Agree. Always, Always, Always understand what they are going to stick in you or pull out of you – you should always ask questions. Don’t be bullied. Yes they provide a free service BUT you still have rights.
30. Rosey, Lewes – I had the same procedure about 12 years ago. I could not believe how painful it was & how no anaesthetic was used. The gynae surgeon said to me “are you still with us?” as if it was a joke! Also episiotomy without anaesthetic & stitches after birth without an anaesthetic with the doctor saying “no she won’t feel this”.Wish I could have done it back to him it was extremely painful. In addition I have had several needle breast biopsies in which I was given a toy frog to squeeze to “help with the pain” & this was under private care! Seems it’s always women who have to undergo these procedures without anaesthetic – seems men seem to think we don’t feel pain! How would they like it if a woman handled their genitals in the same way?
31. MaryJo-KingsLynn4, Norfolk – No, as I said in my comment earlier, we should at least be given the choice after the particular procedure is explained. Some, like me, might still go ahead, as the thought of having to go back at a later date and still have that worry if it’s cancer or not…..might supersede the alternative. Others, after having the initial examination might prefer to wait for the much more painful biopsy, if it is required, until they can have it under either the less expensive and intrusive local anaesthetic – or for others a general might be the preferred option. We are all different and that should be acknowledged.
32. jayjay, High Wycombe – I haven’t had that exact procedure but suffer from endometriosis so pap smears and IUD insertions are agonising. There exists in the NHS an imbalance between causing pain and a desire to get the procedure done as quickly as possible. It’s a bit medieval sometimes, like we’re supposed to grin and bear it and not be a drama queen. Men would never stand for it.
33. Linrow, Nottingham, Spain – The exact same thing happened to me in my local clinic in Spain, but without the soft words and encouragement. The woman doctor was angry with me and nobody ever told me what they had been doing. At least now I know she was probably taking a biopsy. But it is brutal, believe me!
34. Katey S, Belfast, United Kingdom – The cervix is always clamped shut except during labour when it contracts and opens – when an instrument is forced through the closed cervix and into the womb the pain is absolutely indescribable. I am astonished this lady had to undergo this procedure without anaesthetic of some kind. I’d not have consented to this unless anaesthetic was offered. Ladies, please get informed about these things!
35. Cathy, Oxford – But the doctor does not always inform the patient in full. And that is where the problem lies.
36. Tammy, Tamworth – Gas and air and pain relief should be routine minimum for procedures like this. Patient should always be given choice of anaesthetic if they wish it. We do not live in undeveloped country and don’t wish to be treated like this.
37. Suzie_Q, Bedford – I had a camera put into my womb and the pain was worse than giving birth by 10 times at least. I should have known what was coming up when I was shown an infantile picture on the ceiling and told to find the fruit that were hidden within the picture. Legs up in a stirrup, expected to look for ‘fruit’, making sounds that I cannot believe were coming from myself. It was degrading and very painful. I ‘whimpered’ the whole way home whilst I was alone. The memory has never left me. Barbaric procedure. Maybe female doctors should experience this then they will be able to tell all doctors just exactly what it is like. I am quite a stoical person normally.
38. sunlover, Manchester – I had this under general – thank god! I did have a hysteroscopy with only a local anaesthetic and it was awful. The fact that the doctors and nurses downplay it makes you unprepared for what is to come. Presumably it’s also worse if you do actually have anything wrong with you (like fibroids) which may be painful anyway before any poking around is done!
39. Isitme1969, Manchester – This happened to me in November. It was agony. And I have a decent pain threshold. Earlier last year, I was thrown from a horse and hospitalised for three days with broken ribs, fractured vertebrae and punctured… and I didn’t cry then, even though I was in bits waiting for the morphine to kick in. But I certainly did feel the pain during this ‘routine’ hysteroscopy. Immediately afterwards I cried with the relief of it being over. I lay there sweating, trying to hold back the tears. Yes, feeling like a wimp. During the procedure I was told over and over ‘it’s almost done now’ only it wasn’t… it seemed to go on for ages. Women should be told in advance what it involves and be offered pain relief. I wasn’t even advised to take some ibuprofen beforehand – perhaps that would have helped take the excrutiating edge off it! I understand the NHS needs to save money. But at the expense of patients in that much pain?! Crazy.
40. Meatonthebone, Newport – Well done to the Daily Mail for giving great coverage to Hetty Baynes’ horrendous experience. You also covered a similar story about 6 months ago in a letter headed ‘StopThis Torture’. I went through a similar experience to these two ladies a few years ago and am still traumatised by it. If the NHS feels that they have to continue with this barbarism they should at least have the decency to ensure that the patient fully understands what it entails so that they can make an informed decision whether or not to go ahead with it.
41. Doglover1, Chester – I had the same thing without anaesthetic and can agree it was agony. The doctor did not stop it immediately when I asked. He “just wanted to collect a few more cells!”
42. Suzie_Q, Bedford – They didn’t stop for me. ‘Only a little while longer’ was the response and there is not a lot you can do when your legs are up in the stirrups!
43. Mrs D, Donegal – My sister too, they told her to ‘shh, and stop making a fuss’.
44. Tab, UK – I’ve had the same thing and it was horrific. Pain along the lines I have never felt before, I sobbed for 6 hours without stopping. And, yep, five days at least to recover.
45. Qovpatlh, Newcastle, UK – Having experienced childhood sexual assault I can guarantee if this happened to me I’d never go back to a Dr or hospital again. I’d rather die alone in agony than have someone inflict it on me.
46. TLC1, Manchester – The same thing happened to me last year. The procedure is called a hysteroscopy. It was excruciating. Always used to be done under general anaesthetic but because of cost cutting in the NHS it is now done as an out patient. The very least they could do is tell you to take strong painkillers beforehand.
47. SouthernGirl, Southampton, UK – The treatment you have had sounds disgraceful. Unfortunately, only by taking legal action will you stop this happening to somebody else. Changes don’t get made otherwise.
48. Angela Pickles, Elland, UK – I’m not sure it is to do with cuts. I had a similar procedure done in France prior to treatment for fibroids. It was deeply unpleasant and horribly painful and I was in shock and pain for several hours afterwards. It seems to be standard procedure with no warning given that it will be so awful. (If I had been warned I would not have gone through with it!)
49. Puzzled, Reading, UK – I too had this happen to me and because years later I needed another one – I refused unless it was done with anaesthetic. The pain was horrendous and the nurse had to hold me down. I would not recommend any person undergo any invasive surgery without being put out.
50. London Roobarb, London, UK – I was featured in the DM last year; it was me who contacted my MP Lyn Brown. The comments that followed were horrendous! Women need to know the full facts of the procedure so that they can make a fully informed CHOICE as to how they want it carried out whether that is by general anaesthetic, local anaesthetic, conscious sedation or with nothing. The word here is CHOICE! I was given no choice and would rather have gone through 10 labours than that procedure, and women I know were deeply affected by this. Thank you for raising this issue again. I would love to get together with you to discuss how we can move our campaign forward.
51. nimue1, Banwell, UK – The Dr did not explain the procedure properly. The Dr therefore, could not, and indeed, did not, get an officially signed (or verbally agreed) consent, from the patient. This is legally assault and battery, and I do hope that the patient goes to the police about it, and that The Crown Prosecution take it to court.
52. powrightinthekisser, Atlantis, UK – You should sue for money, or else the pain you’ve suffered will be for nought. It should be cancelled out by the extra happy experiences you will have as part of your compensation claim.
53. Banters, Herts – This is a disgrace and makes me doubt the Gynaecologist’s competence. In private practice an internal scan would have been the procedure first employed to identify any potential malignant areas. It is only slightly uncomfortable at most and certainly doesn’t require anaesthetic, but does need a Consultant/Doctor with sufficient skill to interpret the findings. A biopsy would only follow if the results gave cause for concern, using proper pain control. Ms Baynes’ treatment appears to be either a case of poor medical judgement, lack of appropriate equipment, hospital cost-cutting or all three! Our once progressive NHS seems to be going backwards at an alarming rate and is being surpassed by countries we once considered to be medically inferior, why is this being allowed to happen?
54. Cornflower, Birmingham, UK – Yes I agree with her. I had this proceedure done! I was just told by the nurse that it would be a bit painful ! The pain was dreadful. I was screaming and crying so much !!!!
55. ShSh, Surrey – I have had this procedure myself and I hate to tell you all but I went private. It was the worse experience I have ever had. The pain was horrendous, the doctor was cold and the nurse was so rude I had to make a complaint. The experience has now put me off going for regular checks.
56. oldagegoth, Dundee, UK – OMG – I went to an appointment at a Dundee hospital and they did a bioppsy. I’m a tough cookie but what they did was downright abuse. OMG how I screamed. I have had kids and numerous ops for tumours but that was the most brutal thing ever done to me. Traumatised indeed and I feel so sorry for other victims.
57. Sarah, Perth – I am scarred by the memory of the ‘chop’ feeling too!!! Imagine if someone asked if they could chop a little bit off your lip with nail clippers – that’s what it feels like!!! Except you are by no means prepared.
58. Mojo121, Wadhurst, UK – I had exactly the same treatment but in a different hospital. It’s all about saving money. If they don’t give an injection they save money. And yes it is extraordinarily painful.
59. Sharon-S, Wolverhampton – I had endometrial sampling done without anaesthetic or even any numbing injections for heavy bleeding 5 years ago this May with the coil inserted a minute after so it doubled the pain for me. I have gone through childbirth 2 times. The endometrial sampling was totally excruciating and the cramps afterwards were like contractions for 4 days – it was awful. I am dreading having the coil out in a few months time after the time limit is up. I have a very real fear of the pain again though I am hoping it won’t be as bad due to not having the sampling this time.
60. Humph, Norwich, UK – Outpatient procedures do not take up a bed for the day. The patient must not try to travel home alone but, it is otherwise very straightforward. I endured a womb biopsy without pain relief. The pain was so unexpected and shocking that I was unable to repeat it a year later. The later procedure was important being a check for cancer. I hadn’t been warned that my check-up involved another biopsy. Taken by surprise I panicked and signed a disclaimer and fled.
61. The Punisher, Darlington UK – As there was NO CONSENT FORM nor explanation Prosecute for Common Assault. That should concentrate minds.
62. Jane, London – Barbaric, disgusting and an easy trick for doctors to pull, I can see that – but the story wasn’t enhanced by all those photos showing off different poses and outfits. What on earth was that about? It somehow undermines such a serious story, accompanying it with some sort of fashion shoot.
63. Nottingham Miranda, Nottingham – I know you don’t want to sue the NHS but how many more women have undergone this and not complained because they think it’s only them that’s endured it. Trust me, after reading this I thought how barbaric. I would sue them so they can’t do this to another woman
64. JeanyB, Lancashire – It happened to me! I’d had some postmenopausal bleeding so was referred to the hospital. During the procedure one nurse talked non-stop, perhaps she thought I wouldn’t notice the pain if she distracted me! The pain was awful!
65. MrsFit, London – Well done Hetty for raising this issue. There are other procedures that can also be classed as barbaric yet patients are supposed to bear the pain and indignity of them. I doubt the majority of medics who carry them out have ever undergone the procedures themselves so have no idea of the agony they inflict. It’s about time this issue was highlighted – we live in the twenty first century not the Dark Ages.
End
