22 March 2015

13 Bloomfield Avenue
BATH
BA2 3AB

David Richmond
President RCOG
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
27 Sussex Place
LONDON N21 4RG

EXCRUCIATINGLY PAINFUL HYSTEROSCOPIES – PARLIAMENT, THE DAILY MAIL

I enjoyed hearing you speak about measuring national outcomes at the BSGE scientific meeting in Norwich 2014. It was great that you valued the experience of individual patients and even questioned, “Were the patients all happy with their care?”

Please could you possibly help improve patients’ experiences and the earlier diagnosis of womb cancer by updating the RCOG’s 2011 Outpatient Hysteroscopy Guidance to allow patients the option of safe conscious sedation, just as their brothers (and sisters) are offered for colonoscopy and gastroscopy?

As a Macmillan CancerVOICE I’ve read over a hundred accounts of excruciatingly painful and traumatic NHS womb biopsies and hysteroscopies – some performed by leading consultant endoscopists at top hospitals. Evidence from patient support groups show that these appalling experiences often deter patients (and even their GPs) from further investigations for cancer.

Lyn Brown MP (West Ham, Labour) has spoken twice in the House on behalf of constituents who’ve been coerced into completing unbearably painful hysteroscopies without anaesthesia. Lyn Brown cites numerous instances of women throughout England being held down by nurses in order to complete a hysteroscopy and thus avoid the expense of sedation or GA.

[The current addresses are:

•https://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201314/cmhansrd/cm131219/debtext/131219-0003.htm#13121967000536

Hansard : 19 December 2013;    and
•https://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmhansrd/cm141218/debtext/141218-0003.htm#14121849000513

Hansard : 18 December 2014]

 

The adresses at the time of the letter were:

• http://www.parliament.uk/business/publications/hansard/commons/todays-commons-debates/read/unknown/507/ 19 December 2013
• http://www.parliament.uk/business/publications/hansard/commons/todays-commons-debates/read/unknown/628/ 18 December 2014

The Daily Mail has twice recently published accounts of NHS gynaecological diagnostic procedures that amounted to assault. Most women are reluctant to sue the NHS and many feel that they simply would not win against the closed ranks of gynae-endoscopists.
• Female check-up that can be more painful than giving birth – and the barbaric clinics that don’t give pain relief – 18 March 2014 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2582994/Female-check-painful-giving-birth-barbaric-clinics-dont-pain-relief.html
• NHS doctors who inflict intimate and agonising surgery on women with NO anaesthetic – 22 January 2015http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2920561/NHS-doctors-inflict-intimate-agonising-surgery-women-NO-anaesthetic-Hetty-Baynes-subjected-uterine-biopsy-NO-ANAESTHETIC.html

I’ve sent the following comment to the Daily Mail:

“The NHS routinely offers men (and women) conscious sedation for colonoscopy. It’s high time the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists amended their Hysteroscopy Guidelines. Come on RCOG – why are you denying women the option of conscious sedation for endoscopy (often with electro-surgery!) of the womb? Yes, some women can tolerate hysteroscopy without anaesthetic but there’s plenty of evidence from womb cancer support groups that many patients are encouraged to complete excruciatingly painful procedures. Well done Hetty, Lyn and Debbie for trying to stop suffering. Modern dentistry is painless. To see the postcode lottery of what each NHS Trust offers in terms of pain relief for hysteroscopy go to www.wombcancervoice.co.uk”

In November 2013 I sent 12 questions under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 to all the English NHS Acute Trusts asking about a woman’s choice of pain control for OP diagnostic and operative Hysteroscopy.
A Freedom of Information Act (2000) survey and analysis of Outpatient Hysteroscopy/Biopsy –
Pain control and Patient Choice in English NHS Hospital Trusts 2013-14 A full set of Q’s and A’s from 124 Acute Trusts are in the public domain at: www.whatdotheyknow.com and at www.wombcancervoice.co.uk
A ppt presentation summarising the findings to the BSGE 2014 Annual Scientific Meeting is attached above.
The results of the FOIA survey are shocking.
A woman’s choice of pain relief for outpatient ‘See-and-Treat’ hysteroscopy in the English NHS is a post-code lottery.
A few Trusts give patients candid information and a choice of effective pain control. Many Trusts deny patients the choice of GA or sedation. Many Trusts fail to use a written consent form. Many Trusts blatantly ignore the RCOG/BSGE Green-top guidance which recommends that painkillers are taken before the procedure. Sadly, the paracetamol and ibuprofen commonly recommended are ineffectual against the searing pain commonly reported.
It is unbelievable that in 2015 some NHS Trusts are performing 15+ minutes of hysteroscopic electrocautery with only ibuprofen and ‘vocal local’ distraction, then tea and a custard cream for shock. Little wonder that women are collapsing in hospital car-parks.
To conclude, please:
1. Will the RCOG support the patient’s right to choose conscious sedation for hysteroscopy and/or endometrial biopsy?
2. Will the RCOG recommend removal of the QIPP which gives NHS Trusts a large financial reward to persuade or sometimes coerce over 80% women to have an outpatient ‘See and Treat’ hysteroscopy with no sedation, epidural or GA?
Yours sincerely
Katharine Tylko-Hill

Macmillan CancerVOICE
www.wombcancervoice.co.uk
Cochrane Gynae Cancer Group Consumer Reviewer
James Lind Womb Cancer Alliance member

cc.
Don Foster MP, (Bath Lib Dem)
Ertan Saridogan, President British Society for Gynaecological Endoscopy
Lyn Brown MP, (West Ham Labour)