INFORMED CONSENT FOR OUTPATIENT HYSTEROSCOPY;
ADVOCATING FOR YOURSELF

As a lawyer (retired) and OPH survivor, I offered to produce this document for the Campaign Against Painful Hysteroscopy. It aims to explain what informed consent means and has some tips on how to advocate for yourself at your appointment for an OPH and/or an endometrial biopsy. I know from experience how difficult that appointment can be, especially when you are anxious, worried and don’t know what may be in store. That’s why equipping yourself with some information and prompts might help you feel more in control. I stress that I am not giving legal advice; these are just my views
- First of all, do your research, find out everything you can about OPH from trusted sources eg NHS, CAPH, RCOG, BSGE, patient.info etc. The best I have found is the RCOG / BSGE Good Practice Paper on Pain Relief and Informed Decision-Making in OPH (2023)
- Treat the patient information sent to you by the hospital / clinic with scepticism; some is good, some is incomplete or disingenuous
- Bear in mind that research has shown clinicians commonly underestimate the pain which women experience. Some may still hold to the belief that women’s bodies are well equipped to tolerate pain or that women are inclined to exaggerate their pain
- Consider taking someone with you to your appointment for support and to speak up for you if at any point you feel unable to do so
- it is a basic principle of the law and of your human rights that no-one has the power to touch you or do anything to you without your consent
- The landmark case of Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board (2015) established that informed consent is a legal requirement before any medical examination, procedure or treatment can lawfully take place (there are some exceptions to this). Consent must be voluntary and can be changed or revoked at any time before or during any medical action. It means that, before you make a decision, you must be given all “material” information, ie everything which a reasonable patient would wish to know, plus everything which you yourself want to know – so you should tell the clinician what is important to you. If you are able to do so, consider telling her/him about anything which may affect your experience of OPH, eg trauma, painful periods, painful intimate examinations etc. S/he must explain to you what the procedure involves, its risks and benefits and any alternative treatments available (including the option to have it carried out under general or regional anaesthesia or under sedation) and also the possible risks of not having the procedure
- if you are given factually incorrect material information or if the clinician omits to give you some material information, that may vitiate your consent. You might like to point this out (tactfully) if you think this has happened
- Consider taking with you copies of a few relevant pages from the RCOG Green Top Guidelines (2024) or the Good Practice Paper (2023); they may help if you forget something, if you want professional support for your requests or if you meet with any resistance
- Remember, you are in control at all times. If you are undecided about whether to have an OPH, say that you want more time, and perhaps ask for an appointment at a later date. It is your decision and yours alone, and you must not be rushed, pressured or coerced into it. Do not consent if you are not ready or if it doesn’t feel right for you. Whilst many women have OPH without any problems, around 1 in 3 experience severe pain and a significant number suffer longer-term physical and psychological harm. OPH is not the right option for everyone
- If the clinician doesn’t offer you what you want (eg pain relief, sedation) or if you don’t feel comfortable with her/him for any reason, you can ask to be referred elsewhere. This might mean you have to wait a little longer and/or travel further, but it may be the right decision for you
- It is good practice for the clinician or an assistant to explain to you what is happening before each stage of the procedure and to check that your consent is still valid
- There should be a chaperone in the room at all times, but remember, her first duty is to her employer (the NHS Trust) and to the clinician, not to you. You are entitled to have a friend or family member with you throughout if you wish
- You have the absolute right to have the procedure paused or stopped completely at any time, for any reason, and you do not have to explain why – it is your body and your decision alone, so don’t allow yourself to be persuaded to continue if you don’t want to do so. The clinician may stop the procedure if it becomes apparent that you are unable to tolerate it, but you shouldn’t rely on this happening – you or your friend or family member should speak up whenever necessary
- If anything is done to you without your consent, or after your consent has been withdrawn or which exceeds the consent you have given, this may constitute a criminal offence (assault / battery) and a civil wrong (trespass to the person). Pursuing either of these actions is likely to prove very difficult and frustrating: a prosecution is unlikely in the absence of physical harm, and a civil case would be extremely expensive with only a limited chance of success. Neither may provide you with an effective remedy. However, you should consider making a formal complaint
- You may feel angry or even sad that you have to go through this process of “fighting” for your basic right to decent care, to be listened to and believed, but until the gender pain gap is closed, women are no longer gaslighted and their experiences are taken seriously, then unfortunately it may be necessary. By chipping away at outdated attitudes and practices, you will be helping not only yourself but also those women who come after you
Some possible questions to ask:
– I am very worried about pain so I need you to be completely honest with me: how painful might it be?
– What kinds of pain relief / local anaesthesia can you give me?
– In your experience, what proportion of women find OPH painful?
– How often does OPH have to be abandoned because a woman is in pain?
– If I decide I want general or regional anaesthesia or sedation, how long would I have to wait?
