The RCOG/BSGE Outpatient Hysteroscopy guidelines are based on a monumental 2013 PhD thesis by Natalie Cooper. Dr Cooper’s thesis reviews the existing medical literature to find the best ways to reduce the pain of outpatient hysteroscopy. The thesis then examines the cost-effectiveness of different modes of investigating heavy menstrual bleeding.
Here is a link to the full thesis. Below are a few extracts of particular interest to the Campaign Against Painful Hysteroscopy. (We have marked a few areas in red.)
Please do check them with the context of the thesis.
https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/4421/1/Cooper13PhD.pdf
AMBULATORY GYNAECOLOGY: GUIDELINES AND
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
Natalie Ann MacKinnon Cooper
A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
School of Clinical and Experimental Medicine
College of Medical and Dental Sciences
University of Birmingham
June 2013
ABSTRACT
The aim of this thesis was to investigate the role of outpatient hysteroscopy in modern gynaecological care by conducting a series of systematic reviews and meta-analyses to examine how the procedure can be optimised to reduce pain and by performing a cost effectiveness analysis.
The systematic reviews concluded that women undergoing outpatient hysteroscopy should take simple analgesia beforehand and that the hysteroscopist should adopt a vaginoscopic approach using a small diameter, rigid hysteroscope and normal saline as the distension medium.
If dilatation of the cervix is required this should be done under a paracervical block.
These findings were incorporated into a clinical guideline and the quality of the evidence that the reviews provided was assessed using the SIGN and GRADE methods.
A comparison of the assessments found that they gave varying estimates of the quality of evidence and that neither offered a perfect solution to the assessment of evidence quality when writing clinical guidance.
**
The economic analysis found that initial testing with outpatient hysteroscopy was the most cost-effective testing strategy for investigation of heavy menstrual bleeding when compared to other diagnostic tests, regardless of a woman’s wish for future fertility or prior treatment with a levonorgestrel intrauterine system.
***
The work for this thesis was conducted between February 2009 and June 2013 whilst I was working at Birmingham Women’s Hospital, initially as a Research Fellow (funded by the Outpatient Polyp Treatment (OPT) Trial, which was funded by the National Institute for Health Research, Health Technology Assessment Programme) and then as a clinical trainee in obstetrics and gynaecology.
***
My greatest thanks have to go to my lead supervisor Justin Clark for introducing me to research and for his continual encouragement, advice and support. He has an inexhaustible enthusiasm for teaching and improving gynaecology care andhas given me numerous opportunities that have allowed me to develop as an academicand a clinician.
***
CHAPTER 1
THESIS OVERVIEW AND OBJECTIVES
In recent years the ‘classical’ inpatient hysteroscopy, which allows gynaecologists to visualise the lining of the womb has evolved into a diagnostic and therapeutic outpatient procedure. The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) has published standards of care stating that ‘outpatient-based diagnostic services should be available in the community and hospital setting, including operative procedures for carefully selected cases’(1). For this to be possible,outpatient hysteroscopy (OPH) needs to be acceptable to patients and to be cost-effective when compared to alternative outpatient diagnostic testing strategies such as transvaginal ultrasound scan (TVS) and global endometrial biopsy (EBx).
The aim of this thesis was to investigate the role of outpatient hysteroscopy in modern gynaecological care.
There are two themes within the thesis. The first examines how outpatient hysteroscopy can be optimised using systematic reviews.
A clinical guideline was then produced to recommend ‘best-practice’ for outpatient hysteroscopy. The quality of the evidencebehind the guideline was then graded and examined using two guideline methods.
The second theme within the thesis looks at the cost-effectiveness of outpatient hysteroscopy and other diagnostic tests in the investigation of heavy menstrual bleeding. The aim of this analysis is to determine the most cost-effective diagnostic strategy for investigating women who present to secondary care with HMB.
***
Chapter 2
Diagnostic andoperative outpatient hysteroscopy is feasible, safe and acceptable to women (2-5), however, the outpatient setting can present many challenges, with the conscious patient being less forgiving of induced discomfort (6).
To examine how outpatient hysteroscopy can be optimised to reduce pain, different aspects of the procedure can be examined and the available alternative options evaluated. For example, is using normal saline as a distension medium less painful than using carbon dioxide? What method of anaesthetising the cervix is the least painful? Can the procedure be performed without passing a vaginal speculum?
The obvious method of controlling pain is to use pharmaceuticals, whether they are anaesthetics or analgesics. Pain from the body of the uterus is relayed by T12 to L2 nerve roots which are notaccessible vaginally (7) and thus cannot be anaesthetised, however the splanchnic plexus nerves (S2-S4)(7) which sense pain from the cervix and lower uterus can be anaesthetised by administering local anaesthetic to the cervix.
Vasovagal reactions during outpatient hysteroscopy are reported to occur in 20% of women in the general population (8). Nerve stimulation duringpassage of instruments through the cervical canal has been suggested as the cause of vasovagal 4 episodes. It has been theorised that blocking the nerves with local anaesthetic may reduce the incidence of attacks (9-11) but there is also a study which has shown conflicting results (12). Individual studies examining the effect of local anaesthetics are often imprecise and hence provide contradictoryresults (13). Local anaesthetic can be applied as an injection directly into the body of the cervix (intracervical or direct cervical block) or to the surrounding tissues(paracervical block), or topically to the uterine cavity (transcervical application) or the ectocervix(topical application), these methods are shown in Figure 2.
Analgesics block pain receptors and prevent pain signals being relayed to the central nervous system. They can be administered before, during or after procedures to reduce pain. Opiate and non-steroidal inflammatory drugs(NSAID’s) have been used to reduce pain during outpatient hysteroscopy as has conscious sedation(6), however no guidance exists on use of analgesics for outpatient hysteroscopy, resulting in eclectic practice.
A compromise between general anaesthesia and analgesics might be to use conscious sedation (i.e. depression of the central nervous system enabling treatment to be carried out, but during which verbal contact with the patient is maintained’(15)) which is widely used in endoscopic procedures of the gastrointestinal system and in dentistry to make unpleasant interventions more acceptable but it is less commonly employed in outpatient hysteroscopy. The Royal College of Anaesthetists has issued guidance on the safe use of conscious sedation by other medical specialties, recommending that a designated trained staff member be responsible for monitoring the patient throughout the sedation and that resuscitation facilities be available (15). This has obvious cost implications on staffing, equipment and recovery areas. To justify these costs there would need to be a large added benefit of using conscious sedation over less compromising medication.
A final group of drugs which may alleviate discomfort during outpatient hysteroscopy are those whichcan dilate the cervix and potentially aid the passage of the hysteroscope into the uterine cavity.
Hysteroscopy is traditionally an inpatient procedure that requires dilatation of the cervix so that large diameter instruments can be passed into the uterine cavity. Blind mechanical dilatation risks perforation of the uterus, especially where the cervical canal provides more resistance i.e. postmenopausal or nulliparous women or those who have had previous cervical surgery or caesarean section(16;17). Studies examining the use of pharmaceutical (antiprogestogens, prostaglandins) and mechanical (laminaria) dilatation of the cervix prior to inpatient hysteroscopy under general anaesthesia have produced conflicting results regarding their effect on dilatation and trauma during the procedure (18-22).
**
The technological advances that have resulted in miniaturisation of endoscopic instruments have done away with the need for routine, painful cervical dilatation. However, a significant minority of women undergoing an outpatient procedure will require cervical dilatation with the risks of excessive pain and potential trauma to the genital tract.
Once the cervix is traversed and the cavity entered a distending medium needs to be instilled to visualise the uterine cavity. A variety of fluid (normal saline, water, sorbitol, dextran and glycine (34-37)) and gaseous (carbon dioxide(38;39)) media have been used. As with any hollow viscous, distension of the uterine cavity causes pain (irritation of T10 -L2 nerve roots). Moreover, spilling of distension medium into the abdominal cavity can be associated withphrenic(C3-5) nerve irritation and referred pain to the shoulder tip and cervical manipulation may cause vagal stimulation resulting in fainting episodes (6).
**
Principal findings of the reviews
The systematic review of local anaesthetic found that pain is reduced during outpatient hysteroscopy with paracervical and intracervical injections of anaesthetic but not with transcervical and topical application. Paracervical injection appears to be the most effective method of administering local anaesthetic for the procedure. Local anaesthetic did not significantly reduce the incidence of vasovagal attacks during outpatient hysteroscopy but there was a beneficial trend.
The analgesia systematic review found that opiates may reduce the pain of outpatient hysteroscopy during the procedure but not without significant side effects, although some of the symptoms experienced (nausea, vomiting, dizziness) could be attributed to the procedure. In one study the side effects attributed to buprenorphine caused high rates of patient dissatisfaction, demonstrating the importance of considering whether the benefit of pain relief outweighs medication side effects. A study, examining mefenamic acid found a significant reduction in post-operative pain at 30 and 60 minutes.
Conscious sedation with midazolam was found to be as effective as intracervical local anaesthetic for reducing pain during outpatient hysteroscopy.Sedation requires regular monitoring and may be associated with inadvertent overdose, requiring reversal.
Hysteroscopists will be experienced in administering an intracervical block but will have far less experience in the use of conscious sedation and are unlikely to feel confident to manage the sedation without an anaesthetist or a second clinician. Additionally, ambulatory gynaecologists who perform colposcopy are already familiar with techniques for anesthetising the cervix when taking biopsies. Thus to ensure patient safety and reduce the number of trained staff required, alternatives to conscious sedation should be used for outpatient hysteroscopy.
***
Out-patient hysteroscopy is a multi-faceted procedure and so there are many factors that contribute towards pain. These can be categorised into patient factors (e.g. menopausal status, reason for hysteroscopy) and procedural factors (e.g. the type of distension media, use of a speculum, use of a rigid or flexible hysteroscope). The small number of studies in the reviewof local anaesthesia meant that there were not enough data to sub-group the patients accordingto menopausal status and indication for hysteroscopy. Confounding due to procedural factorsshould be eradicated on the basis of the study designs being restricted to randomised controlled trials in this review.
Effectiveness of the procedure in sub-groups of patients (e.g. pre-versus post-menopausal, nulliparous versus parous) could not be assessed as all of the studies included mixedpopulations.
There were no studies which used flexible hysteroscopes for vaginoscopy or that compared vaginoscopy to flexible hysteroscopy.
**
Although these conclusions show a benefit of using local anaesthetic, data reviewing the harms could not be reviewed. This is because harms were not explicitly reported by the majority of studies except when referring to symptoms caused by vagal stimulation (hypotension, bradycardia, nausea, vomiting etc.) although it is possible that similar symptoms may arise from intravasation of injected local anaesthetic. Therefore side effects resulting from the use of local anaesthetic for outpatient hysteroscopy are likely to be underestimated. For example, the time taken to perform the block prolongs the procedure and the pain scores may not take into account the pain experienced during injection of local anaesthetic, in itself a painful procedure. In fact it was found in one study that a vaginoscopic approach to hysteroscopy was significantly less painful than having the procedure done traditionally using a vaginal speculum and a local anaesthetic block (33).
Good pain control is important to ensure an efficient outpatient ‘ambulatory’ hysteroscopy service with rapid discharge and high levels of patient satisfaction (6;108). When prescribing analgesia non-steroidal anti-inflammatories should be preferred to opioids as they have fewer side effects but should be avoided in certain patient groups (asthmatics, history of peptic ulceration, allergy).
For investigation of the gastrointestinal tract, which cannot be anaesthetised and may require quashing of the gag reflex, conscious sedation is an invaluable resource. However, conscioussedation requires an experienced clinician to monitor the degree of sedation and possibly reverse the medication (15)and this is an unfamiliar entity to the gynaecologist. As there is no benefit of conscious sedation over paracervical block (a technique familiar to the hysteroscopist and administrable by them) it would seem that conscious sedation should be avoided for outpatient hysteroscopy.
**
… nulliparous women, those who have not been sexually active, have atrophy of the genital tract or who find intimate examinations distressing are likely to find the vaginoscopic approach more acceptable as it obviates the need for stretching the vagina by a bivalve speculum.
**
Is the pain that women feel during a hysteroscopy enough to warrant the use of anaesthetic? It may cause a significant reduction in the amount of pain experienced, however in the majority of studies the mean pain scores felt in the intervention and control groups showed little variation and tended to be low anyway. Then it must be considered that case selection is important when assessing who will benefit the most from the use of local anaesthetic. Parous, pre-menopausal women are less likely to benefit as it is presumed that they have less narrowing of the cervical canal, whereas nulliparous postmenopausal women who will almost certainly have a degree of cervical stenosis may benefit greatly. The results from these reviews cannot quantify this benefit. It may be that altering different aspects of the procedure (e.g. vaginoscopy, warming liquid distension media, distension pressuresetc.) can reduce the pain significantly without having to use local anaesthetic injection. There are obvious cost implications (for equipment and medication, as well as reducing the number of people seen in clinic) of using local anaesthetic for every patient who undergoes an outpatient hysteroscopy.
**
Research trials should also evaluate administration of local anaesthetic, analgesics and hysteroscopic technique in operative outpatient hysteroscopic surgery, which is becomingincreasingly prevalent with technological advances in endoscopic instrumentation
**
It is during blind dilatation of the cervix that perforation of the uterus is most likely to occur. There are subgroups of women (previous caesarean section, nulliparous, postmenopausal, previous loop biopsy) who more often need dilatation of the cervix to facilitate passage of the hysteroscope. A well designed clinical trial should concentrate on these subgroups to assess whether the use of prostaglandins provides a clinically significant reduction in pain, reduces the need for dilatation and incidence of genital tract trauma and whether these benefits outweigh the potential harms (bleeding, laceration, abdominal cramping, fever).
**
Summary
The ideal outpatient hysteroscopy would be pain free. However this is impossible and so the utmost should be done to minimise pain. The seven systematic reviews conducted suggest that in order to optimise success and minimise pain, women undergoing outpatient hysteroscopy should take simple analgesia a short time prior to the procedure and the hysteroscopist should adopt a vaginoscopic approach using a small diameter, rigidhysteroscope and normal saline as the distension medium.If dilatation of the cervix is required, this should be done under aparacervical block. The use of cervical preparation and conscious sedation should not be routinely used.
END OF FIRST SECTION OF THESIS. 2ND SECTION IS ON ECONOMICS.
